The Cost of Tolerating Poor Performance

Tolerating poor performance rarely feels urgent, but over time it impacts productivity, culture, and profitability across the entire business.

Share
RUN · Fair performance management

The Cost of Tolerating Poor Performance

Address recurring performance concerns with evidence, support and a fair process rather than avoidance or blame.

By Jim Courtwood · Updated 16 October 2026 · Practical business guide

Understand the situation before choosing a response

Describe the work and its impact using specific examples. Listen to the people involved and check whether expectations, tools, training, workload and authority are appropriate. A visible problem does not establish its cause or justify a predetermined outcome.

Keep discussions respectful and records accurate. Explain what is being reviewed, agree the next steps and follow through on support you promise. Obtain appropriately qualified advice where employment rights, disciplinary decisions or other legal obligations are involved.

A practical example

Repeated job errors create rework for colleagues. First establish the expected standard and whether instructions, tools, training and workload are adequate. Discuss the specific errors privately, listen to the employee and agree what improvement and support will look like.

Put it into practice

  1. Document observable examples and the operational impact accurately.
  2. Explain the concern and give the employee an opportunity to respond.
  3. Agree realistic expectations, support and a review date.
  4. Seek appropriate advice before warnings, disciplinary action or termination.

Write down the action, the person responsible and the information needed. Set a realistic completion date and a separate review date. If you work alone, make the commitment small enough to complete alongside existing obligations.

Review the result and the limits

Do not treat estimated rework cost as a reason to bypass employment protections. Distinguish underperformance from misconduct, health concerns and process failures; different circumstances require different responses.

At the review, compare what happened with what you expected. Record the assumptions that changed, any unintended effect and what you will retain, revise or stop. Where the consequences need specialist knowledge, bring your records and a specific question to an appropriately qualified adviser.

Further guidance

Fair Work: managing underperformance. Reference checked 16 October 2026. Follow the current requirements and guidance relevant to your own activities and circumstances.

Choose your next step

Explore the relevant business resources or browse the Resource Library. The guides can help you understand the basics and work through many questions independently.

If personal guidance would help, discuss a focused consulting session with your question and background prepared. Consulting is optional; specialist legal, tax, insurance or financial decisions need appropriately qualified advice.